When to Settle and When to Go to Trial in Arkansas
Learn when it’s smarter to settle a criminal case or go to trial in Arkansas. Understand the risks, benefits, and how to choose the best legal strategy.
CRIMINAL DEFENSE
Do Lawyers Prefer to Settle?
Experienced criminal defense lawyers don’t “prefer” anything—they strategize. That said, many criminal cases in Arkansas (over 90%) resolve through plea deals, not jury trials. That’s not laziness. Sometimes, it is the option that secures the best outcome.
Here’s why:
Prosecutors are open to deals that reduce your charges or sentencing exposure
Trials are risky, expensive, and emotionally draining
Settling early can avoid a felony conviction or years in prison
But this only works when your lawyer uses negotiation as leverage, not default. That’s why it's critical to choose a criminal defense attorney in Arkansas who knows both sides of the battle.
Is It Better to Settle or Go to Trial?
The answer: It depends. See a settlement/trial comparison table below.
Every Arkansas criminal case comes down to one core decision: Do you take the deal—or take it to trial? Both paths come with serious consequences. But the right answer depends on your case, your goals, and your lawyer’s strategy.
Ludwig Law Firm's criminal defense attorneys approach every case with one goal: protecting your future. That may mean settling before trial, or gearing up for a full courtroom fight. We are prepared for both.
As always - if you have a legal question you want answered in a future blog, submit it above! Now, let's dive in.


A Winning Strategy Needs a Winning Lawyer
You need an attorney who understands when to settle, when to fight, and how to spot the difference.
That’s why we often work closely with trial-focused attorneys like Harry Warden of Warden Law Firm, a Super Lawyers Rising Star known for his courtroom presence. We refer high-stakes litigation to Warden Law when clients want an aggressive trial strategy—and they trust us to handle sensitive negotiations with precision.
Ready to Make the Right Move?
If you’re facing charges in Arkansas, don’t guess your way through settlement vs. trial decisions. Let Ludwig Law Firm guide you with wisdom, care, and strength. Call 501-838-4043 or visit ludwiglawfirm.com today.
📞 Call Ludwig Law Firm today at 501-838-4043
🌐 Visit us at ludwiglawfirm.com
📍 Proudly serving clients across Arkansas
Disclaimer: The information provided in this blog is for general informational purposes only and is not intended as legal advice. Reading this blog or interacting with Ludwig Law Firm through this content does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every legal case is different, and you should not act or rely on any information in this blog without first consulting with a licensed attorney about your specific situation. For legal guidance tailored to your needs, please contact Ludwig Law Firm directly.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Do most Arkansas criminal lawyers avoid trial?
A: Many do, but the best lawyers are ready for both. You need someone who fights strategically, not someone who settles everything by default.
Q: Can you negotiate a deal even after a trial starts?
A: Sometimes, yes. Deals can happen at any stage before the verdict.
Q: Should I settle even if I’m innocent?
A: It depends on the strength of the state’s case and your personal risk tolerance. Your lawyer should help you weigh every factor.